How do auditors perform substantive testing under Ind AS?

Meta Description: A comprehensive guide for Indian business owners on how auditors perform substantive testing under Ind AS. Understand the procedures, types, and importance of ensuring your financial statements are accurate and compliant.

As a business owner in India, have you ever wondered what auditors are actually looking for when they go through your financial records? An audit isn’t just a regulatory formality; it’s a deep dive meant to verify the accuracy and fairness of your financial statements. The core of this verification process is known as “substantive testing,” a critical set of procedures designed to find any material misstatements. This blog post will demystify the process of substantive testing under Ind AS (Indian Accounting Standards), explaining what your auditors do, why they do it, and what it means for the health and credibility of your business. Understanding these Ind AS auditing practices can help you prepare for a smoother audit and build stronger financial controls within your organization.

Understanding the Fundamentals: What is Substantive Testing?

Substantive testing is the bedrock of any financial audit. It consists of procedures performed by an auditor to detect material misstatements, which are errors or omissions significant enough to influence the decisions of someone reading the financial statements. Unlike other tests that check your company’s internal processes, substantive tests are designed to directly validate the numbers, balances, and disclosures presented in your financial reports. For a business owner, this means the auditor is not just taking your word for it; they are seeking direct evidence to support the figures in your balance sheet and profit and loss account. This verification is essential for providing assurance to investors, lenders, and regulators that the financial information is reliable and trustworthy.

The Two Pillars of Auditing: Tests of Controls vs. Substantive Testing

To truly grasp substantive testing, it’s helpful to compare it with the other main type of audit procedure: tests of controls. Think of them as two different but complementary ways an auditor gathers evidence. Tests of controls are focused on evaluating the effectiveness of your company’s internal control systems in preventing or detecting errors. This aligns closely with the Primary Purpose of Internal Audit in the Modern Organization. For instance, an auditor might check if your company has a policy requiring two signatures for any payment above ₹50,000 and then test whether this policy is being followed consistently. On the other hand, substantive testing focuses on the end result—the numbers themselves. Even if the two-signature rule exists and is followed (a strong control), substantive testing will still involve procedures to confirm that the ₹50,000 payments were for legitimate business expenses and recorded correctly.

A simple analogy helps clarify the difference:

Tests of Controls is like a food critic checking if the chef is following the recipe, washing their hands, and using fresh ingredients. It’s about the process.
Substantive Testing is the critic actually tasting the final dish to confirm it’s delicious, cooked correctly, and matches the description on the menu. It’s about the outcome.

Aspect	Tests of Controls	Substantive Testing
Primary Goal	To evaluate the effectiveness of internal controls.	To detect material misstatements in financial statements.
Focus	Process and Procedures	Financial Data (Amounts and Disclosures)
Question Answered	“Are the company’s systems working as intended?”	“Are the numbers in the financial statements correct?”
Example	Verifying if invoices are approved before payment.	Confirming year-end bank balances with the bank directly.

Why Substantive Testing Matters for Your Business in India

For any Indian business operating under the Companies Act, 2013, understanding the importance of substantive testing is crucial. This is not just an auditor’s technical exercise; it has direct implications for your business’s reputation and success. It is a fundamental component of Ind AS compliance testing for auditors, ensuring that your financial reporting adheres to the legally mandated accounting standards.

Ensures Accuracy: The primary benefit is verifying that your financial statements are free from major errors. This accuracy is the foundation of sound business decision-making, both internally for your management team and externally for stakeholders.
Builds Credibility: When an auditor provides an unqualified (or “clean”) opinion after performing extensive substantive testing, it signals to the outside world that your financial information is reliable. This builds immense trust with banks when you seek a loan, with investors considering funding your growth, and even with major customers or suppliers assessing your financial stability.
Detects Irregularities: While not primarily designed to detect fraud, auditors substantive testing procedures are often the very means by which financial irregularities or significant internal errors are brought to light, triggering specific Fraud Reporting: Obligations of Auditors and Employees Under Section 143. Uncovering these issues early can save the company from larger financial and legal problems down the line.
Ensures Compliance: Adherence to Indian Accounting Standards (Ind AS) is mandatory for many companies in India. Substantive testing directly validates the figures and disclosures required by these standards, ensuring your business meets its statutory obligations and avoids potential penalties.

The Core Process: How Auditors Perform Substantive Testing under Ind AS

The process of substantive testing under Ind AS is not random or haphazard; it is a systematic and risk-based approach designed to efficiently and effectively gather audit evidence. Substantive testing auditors India follow a structured methodology to ensure all key financial statement assertions—such as existence, completeness, valuation, and rights and obligations—are thoroughly examined. For a business owner, knowing these steps can help you anticipate the auditor’s requests and facilitate a more collaborative audit process.

Step 1: Planning and Risk Assessment

The audit begins long before the auditors start asking for documents. The first and most critical step is planning and risk assessment. Auditors understand that it is impractical and inefficient to check every single transaction a company makes throughout the year. Instead, they use their professional judgment to identify areas where the risk of material misstatement is highest. For example, a software company’s revenue recognition might be a high-risk area due to its complexity, whereas for a manufacturing company, the valuation of inventory might be the bigger concern. The audit team will gain an understanding of your business, its industry, and its internal controls to create a tailored audit plan that focuses intensive testing efforts on these high-risk areas while applying less detailed procedures to lower-risk accounts.

Step 2: Substantive Analytical Procedures

Once the plan is in place, one of the first types of substantive tests performed is analytical procedures. This involves evaluating financial information by studying plausible relationships among both financial and non-financial data. Essentially, auditors look at the ‘big picture’ to spot trends, fluctuations, or relationships that seem unusual or don’t make sense. If these anomalies are identified, they are flagged for more detailed investigation. These procedures are powerful because they can quickly highlight potential problem areas.

Simple examples of analytical procedures include:

Trend Analysis: Comparing your company’s sales figures on a month-to-month basis. A sudden, sharp spike in sales in the final month of the year without a clear business reason could be a red flag for improper revenue recognition.
Ratio Analysis: Comparing your gross profit margin from this year to the previous year and to industry averages. A significant and unexplained deviation could indicate issues with either sales or cost of goods sold.
Reasonableness Testing: Comparing the total salary expense on the income statement to the average number of employees and their average salaries. If the expense seems disproportionately high, it warrants further investigation.

Step 3: Tests of Details

This is the most well-known part of the audit, where the auditors get into the “nitty-gritty” of your transactions and balances. When analytical procedures indicate a potential issue or for high-risk accounts, auditors perform tests of details to gather specific evidence. These are the core auditors substantive testing procedures that directly verify the figures in your books. Here’s how auditors perform testing India using these methods:

Inspection: This involves the physical examination of assets or the detailed review of records and documents. For example, an auditor will physically observe your year-end inventory count to confirm the quantities of stock you claim to have. They will also inspect documents like signed sales contracts, property deeds, and loan agreements to verify terms and existence.
External Confirmation: This is a highly reliable form of evidence where the auditor obtains verification directly from an independent third party. The most common example is sending a letter to your company’s bank to confirm your account balances as of the financial year-end. Similarly, they may send letters to a sample of your customers to confirm the amount they owe you (accounts receivable).
Recalculation: Here, the auditor independently checks the mathematical accuracy of your figures. This includes recalculating things like the depreciation expense on your assets, accrued interest on loans, or provisions for employee benefits to ensure they have been computed correctly according to Ind AS.
Vouching & Tracing: These are two fundamental techniques used to test transactions.
- Vouching: This tests for existence or occurrence. The auditor starts with an entry in your financial statements (e.g., a large expense entry) and works backward to find the supporting source document (like the original supplier invoice and proof of payment). This confirms that the recorded transaction actually happened and is legitimate.
- Tracing: This tests for completeness. The auditor starts with a source document (e.g., a stack of shipping documents for goods sent to customers) and traces it forward to ensure it has been properly recorded as a sale in your accounting system. This helps confirm that all transactions that should have been recorded were, in fact, recorded.

Common Examples: Types of Substantive Testing in Action

To make the concept of substantive testing more concrete, let’s look at how it’s applied to some of the most common accounts in a company’s financial statements. These examples showcase the various types of substantive testing India-based auditors use to gain assurance over key balances.

Verifying Cash and Bank Balances

This is one of the most straightforward but critical areas of an audit. The primary risk is that the cash reported on the balance sheet doesn’t actually exist or is overstated.

Procedure: The auditor’s primary tool here is external confirmation. They will independently prepare and send a confirmation request directly to every bank where your company holds an account. The bank then sends a reply directly back to the auditor, confirming the account balances, any liens on the accounts, and details of any loans. The auditor will also review your year-end bank reconciliation statements to check for any unusual or old outstanding items.
Purpose: To confirm the existence and accuracy of the cash balances and to understand the company’s rights to that cash.

Testing Accounts Receivable (Money Owed by Customers)

Accounts receivable represents the money your customers owe you. The risks here are that these receivables are not genuine (fake sales were booked), are not valued correctly (the customer is unlikely to pay), or don’t belong to the company.

Procedure: The auditor will select a sample of customer balances and send them confirmation letters, asking them to confirm the amount they owe your company as of the year-end. They will also perform subsequent cash receipts testing, which involves checking payments received from these customers *after* the year-end to see if they settled the outstanding balance. For any balances that seem doubtful, the auditor will review the adequacy of the provision for bad debts.
Purpose: To confirm the existence, valuation, and rights to the accounts receivable.

Auditing Inventory

For manufacturing and retail businesses, inventory is often one of the largest assets on the balance sheet. The key risks are that the inventory doesn’t exist, is obsolete and overvalued, or is not owned by the company.

Procedure: A cornerstone procedure is the physical inventory observation. The auditor will be present during your year-end stock count to observe your team’s procedures and perform their own test counts on a sample basis. They will also test the valuation of the inventory by checking supplier invoices to confirm its cost and assessing whether it needs to be written down to its ‘net realizable value’ (the expected selling price less costs to sell) as required by Ind AS. For more details on these standards, you can refer to the official resources on Indian Accounting Standards (Ind AS) by the Ministry of Corporate Affairs.
Purpose: To confirm the existence, completeness, valuation, and ownership of the inventory.

Conclusion

Substantive testing is much more than a box-ticking exercise; it is a critical audit process that underpins the reliability of financial reporting in India. By verifying the accuracy of financial numbers through a combination of high-level analytical reviews and detailed, evidence-based checks, auditors provide the assurance that stakeholders need. For business owners, understanding the process of substantive testing under Ind AS is empowering. It helps you maintain more accurate records throughout the year, anticipate the needs of your auditors, build undeniable trust with banks and investors, and ultimately, ensure a smooth and efficient audit.

Preparing for an audit can be challenging. Let TaxRobo’s expert accounting and auditing services ensure your business is compliant and audit-ready. Contact us today for a consultation!

FAQ Section

Q1: What happens if an auditor finds an error during substantive testing?
A: If an auditor discovers an error, they will first assess if it is a minor, isolated issue or a ‘material’ misstatement that could mislead a user of the financial statements. If the error is considered material, they will communicate it to the company’s management and request that they correct the financial statements. If management refuses to make the necessary correction, the auditor will have to issue a modified opinion in their final audit report, which can negatively impact the company’s credibility.

Q2: Can good internal controls reduce the amount of substantive testing?
A: Yes, absolutely. This is a key principle of the risk-based audit approach. If an auditor tests a company’s internal controls (e.g., procedures for approving purchases or reconciling bank accounts) and finds them to be strong, effective, and consistently applied, they can gain a degree of confidence that the financial data is likely to be accurate. This allows them to reduce the extent of detailed substantive testing required, making the audit more efficient.

Q3: Is substantive testing mandatory for all companies in India?
A: Substantive testing is a fundamental and non-negotiable part of a financial statement audit conducted under the Standards on Auditing. Therefore, if your company is required by law (such as the Companies Act, 2013) to undergo a statutory audit, then it is mandatory for the auditor to perform substantive testing to form an opinion on your financial statements.

Q4: As a business owner, what documents should I keep ready for the auditors’ substantive testing procedures?
A: Being organized can significantly speed up the audit process. In addition to specific documents, having a mindset of Staying Audit-Ready: Tips for Continuous Compliance is crucial. You should have a comprehensive set of documents readily available for the auditors substantive testing procedures. Key documents include: