Section 143: Understanding the Powers and Duties of Auditors Under the Companies Act 2013

Introduction: Why Understanding Auditor Roles Matters for Your Business

In the vibrant landscape of Indian business, trust and transparency are paramount. Whether you’re running a small startup or managing a growing enterprise, ensuring your financial house is in order is crucial for compliance, attracting investment, and building lasting stakeholder confidence. This is where audits play a vital role. But what exactly does an auditor do, and what authority do they have? The answer lies primarily within Section 143 of the Companies Act, 2013, the cornerstone legislation defining the scope of an auditor’s role in India. Understanding this section isn’t just for large corporations; it’s essential knowledge for businesses of all sizes. This blog post aims to break down the specific powers and duties of auditors as outlined in Section 143 companies act India, clarifying their rights and responsibilities. For small business owners, this knowledge is key for smooth audits and robust compliance. For salaried individuals, understanding the auditor’s function provides insight into the governance and reliability of the companies they might invest in or work for. Let’s delve into the crucial aspects of the powers and duties of auditors.

Decoding Section 143 of the Companies Act, 2013

The Companies Act, 2013, represented a significant overhaul of India’s corporate law framework, aiming to modernize regulations, enhance corporate governance, and protect stakeholder interests. Within this comprehensive legislation, Section 143 stands out as it specifically addresses the auditors of a company. It meticulously lays down their rights, the obligations they must fulfill, and the manner in which they must report their findings. Think of Section 143 as the auditor’s rulebook, providing them with the necessary authority to conduct a thorough examination while simultaneously holding them accountable for the quality and integrity of their work. This section significantly strengthens auditors responsibilities in corporate governance by establishing clear statutory backing for their inquiries, reporting requirements, and their overall role in verifying the financial health and compliance of a company. It moves the auditor’s role beyond mere number-checking to that of a critical evaluator operating within a defined legal framework.

Key Powers Granted to Auditors under Section 143

To perform their duties effectively and independently, the Companies Act, 2013, through Section 143, grants auditors specific powers or rights. These powers are not arbitrary but are designed to ensure that auditors have unfettered access to the information required for a comprehensive audit. Understanding these powers helps companies facilitate the audit process efficiently. Let’s explore the fundamental powers and duties of auditors, focusing here on the ‘powers’. These powers of auditors under companies act are essential tools enabling them to fulfil their statutory obligations diligently and form an informed opinion on the financial statements. The effective exercise of these auditors powers and duties India underpins the credibility of the audit itself.

Power 1: Right of Access to Books, Accounts, and Vouchers (Section 143(1))

One of the most fundamental powers bestowed upon an auditor is the right of access, at all times, to the company’s books of account and vouchers. This isn’t limited to just the primary financial ledgers; it encompasses all supporting documents, records, and financial data, regardless of where they are kept – whether at the registered office or any other location where the company maintains its records. This right is absolute and essential for the auditor to perform substantive checks, verify transactions, trace entries back to their source documentation, and satisfy themselves about the authenticity and completeness of the financial information presented. Without this unrestricted access, an auditor cannot realistically form an opinion on whether the financial statements present a ‘true and fair’ view. Companies are legally obligated to provide this access whenever requested by the auditor during the course of their audit.

Power 2: Right to Obtain Information and Explanations (Section 143(1))

Complementing the right of access is the auditor’s power to seek and obtain information and explanations from the company’s officers and employees. Financial records alone may not always provide the full context or rationale behind certain transactions or accounting treatments. Auditors often need clarification on specific entries, company policies, internal control procedures, or management judgments affecting the financial statements. Section 143(1) empowers the auditor to ask pertinent questions and requires the company’s management and staff to provide such information and explanations as the auditor deems necessary for the performance of their duties. This interaction is crucial for the auditor to understand the business operations, assess risks, and evaluate the appropriateness of accounting policies applied by the company. Failure by the company to provide necessary information can be a significant impediment and may need to be reported by the auditor.

Power 3: Right to Access Records of Subsidiaries (in relation to consolidation)

In today’s business environment, many companies operate through a network of subsidiaries, associates, or joint ventures. When an auditor is auditing the financial statements of a holding company, particularly for the purpose of preparing consolidated financial statements, their scope extends beyond the holding company itself. Section 143 grants the auditor the right to access the records of all subsidiaries and associate companies to the extent necessary for the consolidation process. This ensures that the auditor can verify the financial information flowing from these entities into the consolidated accounts, check inter-company transactions, and ensure consistency in accounting policies across the group, thereby ensuring the consolidated financial statements provide a true and fair view of the entire group’s financial position and performance.

Power 4: Right to Attend General Meetings (Section 146)

While technically detailed under Section 146, it’s intrinsically linked to the auditor’s role defined in Section 143. Auditors have the statutory right to receive all notices and communications relating to any general meeting of the company (like the Annual General Meeting or AGM) that members are entitled to receive. Furthermore, they have the right to attend any general meeting, either in person or through an authorized representative (who must also be a qualified auditor). Crucially, auditors have the right to be heard at these meetings on any part of the business that concerns them as auditors. This allows them to directly address the shareholders, answer queries related to their audit report, or bring attention to any significant matters arising from the audit, ensuring transparency and direct accountability to the members.

Core Duties and Responsibilities of Auditors under Section 143

Alongside the powers granted, Section 143 imposes significant duties and responsibilities on auditors. These obligations define the scope and objective of their work, ensuring they act diligently, professionally, and in the interest of the company’s members (shareholders). These duties of auditors in India form the bedrock of auditing under companies act 2013, ensuring that audits are conducted with a specific purpose and adhere to legal requirements. Fulfilling these duties is central to the auditor’s role in maintaining financial integrity and requires a thorough understanding of both accounting principles and the legal landscape defined by the Act. The interplay between the powers and duties of auditors ensures a balanced and effective audit function. Let’s examine the core responsibilities of auditors in companies act.

Duty 1: Duty to Inquire (Section 143(1))

Beyond merely verifying the numbers presented, auditors have a specific statutory duty under Section 143(1) to inquire into certain critical matters during their audit. This proactive duty requires them to investigate specific areas that could indicate financial impropriety or mismanagement, even if they don’t immediately appear problematic on the face of the accounts. The key areas of mandatory inquiry include:

• Security for Loans and Advances: Whether loans and advances made by the company on the basis of security are properly secured and whether the terms are prejudicial to the company’s interests.
• Book Entries: Whether transactions represented merely by book entries (i.e., without underlying substance or documentation) are prejudicial to the interests of the company.
• Sale of Investments (Non-Investment/Banking Co.): For companies not primarily dealing in investments or banking, whether substantial assets held as investments (like shares, debentures) have been sold at a price less than their purchase cost.
• Loans Shown as Deposits: Whether loans and advances made by the company have been incorrectly shown as deposits in the books.
• Personal Expenses: Whether any personal expenses of directors or employees have been charged to the company’s revenue account (profit and loss).
• Shares Allotted for Cash: Where shares are stated to have been allotted for cash, whether cash has actually been received and if the accounting for this is correct in the books.

This duty to inquire highlights that the auditor’s role involves skepticism and investigation into potentially high-risk areas.

Duty 2: Duty to Report to Members (Section 143(2) & 143(3))

Perhaps the most crucial duty of an auditor is to report their findings to the members (shareholders) of the company. Section 143(2) mandates that the auditor prepares a report on the accounts examined by them and on every financial statement required by law to be laid before the company in a general meeting. Section 143(3) details the essential elements that this audit report must cover. The auditor must state, to the best of their information and knowledge, whether the accounts and financial statements give a true and fair view of:

• The company’s state of affairs at the end of the financial year.
• The profit or loss for the financial year.
• The cash flow for the financial year (where applicable).

Furthermore, the report must explicitly state:

• Whether they have sought and obtained all the information and explanations which were necessary for the audit.
• Whether, in their opinion, proper books of account as required by law have been kept by the company.
• Whether the company’s balance sheet, profit and loss account, and cash flow statement dealt with in the report are in agreement with the books of account.
• Whether the financial statements comply with the prescribed Accounting Standards (AS/Ind AS).
• Any observations or comments on financial transactions or matters which have an adverse effect on the functioning of the company.
• Any qualifications, reservations, or adverse remarks relating to the maintenance of accounts and other matters connected therewith.
• Specific reporting requirements under the Companies (Auditor’s Report) Order (CARO), if applicable.

This detailed reporting ensures transparency and provides shareholders with a reliable assessment of the company’s financial health and management’s accountability.

Duty 3: Reporting on Internal Financial Controls (IFC) (Proviso to Section 143(3)(i))

A significant addition under the Companies Act, 2013, is the requirement for auditors of certain classes of companies (including listed companies and larger unlisted public companies) to report on the adequacy and operating effectiveness of the company’s Internal Financial Controls (IFC) system concerning financial reporting. In simple terms, IFC refers to the policies and procedures adopted by the company to ensure:

• The orderly and efficient conduct of its business.
• Safeguarding of its assets.
• Prevention and detection of frauds and errors.
• Accuracy and completeness of accounting records.
• Timely preparation of reliable financial information.

While this requirement might not apply directly to all small private companies yet, understanding its importance underscores the emphasis the Act places on robust internal processes. For companies where this applies, the auditor must explicitly state in their report whether the company has an adequate IFC system in place and whether it was operating effectively during the year. This duty pushes companies towards strengthening their internal checks and balances.

Duty 4: Duty to Report Fraud (Section 143(12))

This is one of the most critical and stringent Section 143 duties of auditors India. Auditors are legally mandated to report fraud if, during their audit, they have reason to believe that an offence involving fraud is being or has been committed against the company by its officers or employees. This is not optional; it’s a statutory obligation. The reporting mechanism depends on the amount involved:

• Fraud Amount Below Threshold (Currently < INR 1 Crore): If the suspected fraud amount is less than Rupees One Crore, the auditor must immediately report the matter to the company’s Audit Committee (if one exists) or the Board of Directors within two days of gaining knowledge of the fraud. This report should detail the nature of the fraud, the approximate amount involved, and the parties suspected. The Board’s report must then disclose details of such frauds reported by the auditor.
• Fraud Amount Above Threshold (Currently >= INR 1 Crore): If the suspected fraud involves Rupees One Crore or more, the auditor must first report it to the Board/Audit Committee within two days. They must seek a reply/observations from the Board/Audit Committee within 45 days. Within 15 days of receiving the reply (or expiry of 45 days if no reply is received), the auditor must forward their report, along with the reply (if any) and their comments on the reply, to the Central Government (specifically, the Secretary, Ministry of Corporate Affairs – MCA). This reporting to the MCA is done using Form ADT-4.

Here’s a quick summary:

Scenario	Amount Involved	Initial Reporting To	Reporting Timeframe (Initial)	Further Reporting To	Reporting Timeframe (Further)	Form
Fraud by Officer/Employee against Company	Less than INR 1 Crore	Board / Audit Committee	Within 2 days of knowledge	N/A	N/A	N/A
Fraud by Officer/Employee against Company	INR 1 Crore or more	Board / Audit Committee	Within 2 days of knowledge	Central Govt (MCA)	Within 60 days from Board Rpt date*	Form ADT-4

*Note: The 60 days comprises 45 days for Board reply + 15 days for auditor to report to MCA.

This duty places a significant responsibility on auditors for fraud detection and escalation, making them key gatekeepers in preventing corporate misconduct.

Duty 5: Compliance with Auditing Standards

Underlying all other duties is the fundamental obligation outlined in Section 143(9) for every auditor to comply with the Standards on Auditing (SAs). These standards are issued by the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India (ICAI) and provide detailed guidance on the principles and procedures auditors must follow when conducting an audit. Compliance with SAs ensures a minimum quality benchmark for audits, covering aspects like planning, risk assessment, evidence gathering, documentation, and reporting. Failure to comply with SAs can lead to disciplinary action against the auditor. This duty ensures that the audit process itself is robust, systematic, and adheres to professional best practices, thereby enhancing the reliability of the audit opinion.

Why Section 143 Matters: Implications for Your Business

Understanding the scope of Section 143, encompassing both the powers and duties of auditors, is not just an academic exercise; it has direct practical implications for your business, especially for small and medium enterprises. Knowing what your auditor is empowered and obligated to do helps you navigate the audit process more effectively and ensures you meet your own compliance requirements. Being aware of the auditor’s right of access and right to information prompts businesses to maintain organized records and foster a culture of cooperation, which ultimately leads to a smoother, more efficient audit. This proactive approach minimizes disruptions and potential delays.

Furthermore, understanding the auditor’s duties, particularly regarding reporting on financial accuracy, internal controls (where applicable), and the mandatory fraud reporting, reinforces the importance of maintaining accurate books of account and establishing strong internal procedures within your own company. These aren’t just ‘good practices’; they are essential for compliance and mitigating risks identified under the companies act 2013 implications for auditors. Demonstrating compliance with statutory audit requirements significantly enhances your company’s credibility with banks, potential investors, suppliers, and customers. A clean audit report signals financial health and good governance. Conversely, non-compliance, obstructing the auditor, or failing to maintain proper records can lead to qualified audit reports, regulatory penalties, difficulties in securing finance, and significant damage to your business’s reputation.

Conclusion: Navigating Auditor Responsibilities for a Compliant Business

Section 143 of the Companies Act, 2013, serves a dual purpose: it empowers auditors with the necessary rights to conduct a thorough examination while simultaneously imposing critical duties that ensure accountability and transparency. It establishes the framework within which auditors operate, acting as independent verifiers of a company’s financial health and compliance stature. For businesses in India, comprehending the powers and duties of auditors is not merely about passing the annual audit; it’s fundamental to practicing good corporate governance, ensuring legal compliance, and building a sustainable, trustworthy enterprise. Auditors, through the diligent exercise of their powers and fulfilment of their duties, play an indispensable role in the financial ecosystem. Cooperating with them and understanding their mandate ultimately benefits your company by fostering financial discipline and enhancing stakeholder confidence in the long run. Understanding these powers and duties of auditors is a key step towards robust business management.

Need assistance with auditing, accounting, or ensuring your company complies with the intricate requirements of the Companies Act, 2013? Don’t navigate these complexities alone. Contact TaxRobo today for expert guidance and professional services tailored to your business needs. Link to TaxRobo’s Auditing/Compliance Service Page

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) about Auditor Powers and Duties

Q1. Can an auditor demand any document or information from my company?

A: Auditors possess broad rights under Section 143(1) to access books, accounts, vouchers, and seek information and explanations that they deem necessary for the purpose of conducting their audit. This power is extensive but not unlimited; the documents and information requested must be relevant to the scope of their audit engagement and their statutory duties. While companies must cooperate fully, if a request seems entirely unreasonable or irrelevant to the financial audit, it’s advisable to have an open discussion with the auditor to understand the rationale behind the request. However, withholding relevant information necessary for the audit is a violation of the Act.

Q2. What is the auditor’s responsibility if they suspect minor fraud by an employee in my small business?

A: The duty to report fraud under Section 143(12) applies to any suspected fraud committed against the company by its officers or employees, regardless of the amount initially perceived as ‘minor’. If the amount involved is believed to be less than the prescribed threshold (currently INR 1 Crore), the auditor has a strict duty to report the matter (including nature, approximate amount, and parties involved) to the company’s Board of Directors or Audit Committee (if applicable) within two days of forming such belief. The Board/Audit Committee is then expected to take note and potentially initiate remedial action. The key takeaway from Section 143 duties of auditors India is that even seemingly small internal frauds fall under this reporting duty to the management level.

Q3. Do auditors only look for financial mistakes?

A: No, the scope of an auditor’s work under the Companies Act, 2013 goes significantly beyond just searching for calculation errors or unintentional financial mistakes. While ensuring the financial statements present a ‘true and fair’ view is a primary objective, their responsibilities of auditors in companies act are much broader. They must actively inquire into specific high-risk transactions (as listed under Section 143(1)), evaluate compliance with Accounting Standards and relevant laws, assess the adequacy and effectiveness of internal financial controls (for applicable companies), comment on matters adversely affecting the company’s functioning, and crucially, report any suspected fraud against the company by its officers or employees. Their role involves judgment, skepticism, and a holistic view of the company’s financial reporting environment.

Q4. As a small business owner, how should I interact with the auditor regarding their powers and duties?

A: The most effective approach is to be cooperative, transparent, and prepared. Ensure that your books of account and supporting documents are well-maintained and readily available. Respond promptly and honestly to the auditor’s requests for information and explanations. Understand that their inquiries, even if they seem detailed, are part of fulfilling their statutory duties under auditing under companies act 2013. Designate a point person within your company to liaise with the audit team. Fostering open communication and providing timely access can significantly streamline the audit process, making it more efficient and less disruptive for your business operations. View the audit not just as a compliance burden, but as an opportunity to gain valuable insights into your financial processes.

Q5. Why are the powers and duties of auditors important for people who aren’t business owners, like employees or investors?

A: The powers and duties of auditors are fundamental to the integrity of the financial reporting system, which benefits many stakeholders beyond just the business owners or management. For investors (current or potential), the auditor’s independent report provides crucial assurance about the reliability of the company’s financial statements, informing their investment decisions. For lenders and creditors, the audit report helps assess the company’s creditworthiness and financial stability. For employees, a clean audit report can signify good governance and financial health, contributing to job security and trust in the company’s leadership. The auditor’s role in auditors responsibilities in corporate governance, including fraud reporting, acts as a safeguard for all stakeholders by promoting accountability and ethical conduct within the company. Therefore, a strong and independent audit function benefits the entire economic ecosystem. For more insights on how auditing impacts modern organizations, explore Primary Purpose of Internal Audit in the Modern Organization.

Additional Considerations

For small business owners looking to set up a robust accounting framework that can ease interaction with auditors, consider reading Set Up An Accounting System for My Small Business. Compliance and correct record-keeping are essential components that facilitate a smooth auditing process and align with the statutory obligations outlined in the Companies Act 2013.

Learn more about the role of auditors and how it relates to other corporate responsibilities such as taxation and filing by visiting our detailed guide on Taxation Services In India.